阅读下面的材料,根据要求写作。
Read the following material and write according to the requirements.
有人说:当今社会,贫困的最大责任在于自己。你是否认同,请写一篇文章,谈谈你的看法。
Some people say that in today's society, the greatest responsibility for poverty lies with oneself. Do you agree? Please write an article to share your opinion.
要求:(1)自拟题目;(2)不少于800字。
Requirement: (1) Self drafted topic; (2) Not less than 800 words.
【文题解析】:
Title analysis:
这是一道引语式材料作文题。
This is a quote based material essay topic.
“贫困的最大责任在于自己”这一观点,本质是将贫困归因于个人能力、努力程度或选择偏差,强调个体主观能动性对摆脱贫困的决定性作用。其争议核心在于:是否忽视了贫困背后的客观环境制约——如地域资源差异、家庭背景限制、社会制度壁垒等,陷入“唯个人主义”的认知误区。从现实来看,该观点有一定合理性(个人努力确实是脱贫的重要因素),但“最大责任”的表述过于绝对,需辩证看待个体与环境的双重影响。
The viewpoint that 'the greatest responsibility for poverty lies with oneself' essentially attributes poverty to individual abilities, efforts, or selection biases, emphasizing the decisive role of individual subjective initiative in escaping poverty. The core of its controversy lies in whether it ignores the objective environmental constraints behind poverty, such as regional resource differences, family background limitations, social system barriers, etc., and falls into the cognitive misconception of "individualism only". From a practical perspective, this viewpoint has some rationality (personal efforts are indeed an important factor in poverty alleviation), but the expression of "maximum responsibility" is too absolute and requires a dialectical view of the dual impact of individuals and the environment.
对此,我们应承认个人责任可激励人主动改变现状,避免“等靠要”的消极心态。但若过度强调“个人责任”,易掩盖社会资源分配不均、公共服务缺失等问题。因此,立意时,应避免“非黑即白”,不可全盘否定或肯定该观点,体现出辩证思维。
In this regard, we should acknowledge that personal responsibility can motivate people to actively change the status quo and avoid a negative mentality of "waiting and relying". However, excessive emphasis on "personal responsibility" can easily conceal problems such as unequal distribution of social resources and lack of public services. Therefore, when formulating ideas, one should avoid "either black or white" and not completely negate or affirm the viewpoint, reflecting dialectical thinking.
写作时,可联系社会现实引出中心论点,如贫困的责任并非单一归属,个人努力是脱贫的“内生动力”,社会支持是脱贫的“外在保障”,二者共同构成脱贫的关键。主体部分,可采用分论点的形式,体现出辩证思维。首先论述“个人责任是摆脱贫困的‘基石’”,可列举“寒门学子考上名校”的新闻,论证个人主动奋斗能突破部分环境限制,是脱贫的首要前提;再从反面补证,强调“环境制约是贫困的‘不可忽视之因’”,可列举偏远山区孩子因学校师资薄弱导致升学率低的事例,说明当客观条件极端不利时,仅靠个人努力难以承担“最大责任”,需社会力量介入;接着,进一步指出,“个人与社会协同,方能破解贫困困局”,强调“个人为舟,社会为帆”的协同效应,比单一强调“个人责任”更具现实意义。结尾部分,呼应前文,重申论点。
When writing, one can connect with social reality to introduce the central argument, such as that the responsibility for poverty is not solely attributed, individual efforts are the "endogenous driving force" for poverty alleviation, and social support is the "external guarantee" for poverty alleviation, both of which together constitute the key to poverty alleviation. The main body can be presented in the form of sub arguments, reflecting dialectical thinking. Firstly, it is argued that 'personal responsibility is the cornerstone' of poverty alleviation. 'This can be exemplified by news of' students from humble backgrounds being admitted to prestigious universities', demonstrating that proactive personal efforts can overcome some environmental limitations and are the primary prerequisite for poverty alleviation; Further supporting evidence from the opposite side, emphasizing that "environmental constraints are an 'undeniable cause' of poverty", examples of children in remote mountainous areas having low enrollment rates due to weak school teachers can be cited to illustrate that when objective conditions are extremely unfavorable, it is difficult to bear the "maximum responsibility" solely through personal efforts, and social forces need to intervene; Furthermore, it is pointed out that 'collaboration between individuals and society is the only way to overcome poverty', emphasizing the synergistic effect of 'individuals as boats, society as sails', which is more practical than simply emphasizing' individual responsibility '. At the end, echoing the previous text, reiterate the argument.
立意:
conception:
1.贫困非单一归因,个人与社会需共担责任。
Poverty is not solely attributed, and individuals and society need to share responsibility.
2.个人奋斗是脱贫基石,但非唯一答案。
2. Personal struggle is the cornerstone of poverty alleviation, but it is not the only answer.
3.正视环境制约,更要激发个人潜能。
3. Facing environmental constraints, it is even more important to stimulate personal potential.
【佳作赏析】:责任的诗行,生活的旋律
Appreciation of Masterpieces: Poems of Responsibility, Melodies of Life
在晨光的拂晓,我漫步在校园的小径上,耳畔传来的是鸟儿的啁啾和树叶的沙沙声。这样的早晨,总是让人不禁思考,关于生活的种种。
At dawn, I stroll along the campus path, hearing the chirping of birds and the rustling of leaves. This morning always makes people think about various aspects of life.
有人说,当今社会,贫困的最大责任在于自己。这样的说法,如同一阵微风,轻轻拂过我的心湖,泛起层层涟漪。我站在岁月的长河之畔,静静地看着眼前的一切,心中涌现出无数的想法。
Some people say that in today's society, the greatest responsibility for poverty lies with oneself. This statement is like a gentle breeze, gently brushing over the lake of my heart, creating layers of ripples. I stand by the river of time, quietly watching everything in front of me, and countless thoughts arise in my heart.
我想起了那个小村庄,那里的生活虽然贫瘠,但村民们总是面带微笑,他们的眼中闪烁着对生活的热爱。他们知道,生活的艰辛,但他们没有放弃。他们用自己的双手,耕种着土地,养育着家人。他们的责任,是对家庭的责任,是对土地的责任,更是对自己生活的责任。
I thought of that small village, where although life was barren, the villagers always wore smiles and their eyes sparkled with love for life. They know the hardships of life, but they haven't given up. They use their own hands to cultivate the land and raise their families. Their responsibility is to their family, to their land, and even more importantly, to their own lives.
在这样的村庄里,贫困并不是生活的全部。村民们知道,尽管他们生活在贫困之中,但他们依然有能力去改变自己的生活。他们的责任,让他们在艰苦的环境中找到了希望的光芒。
In such a village, poverty is not the entirety of life. The villagers know that although they live in poverty, they still have the ability to change their lives. Their responsibility has allowed them to find the light of hope in difficult environments.
我还记得那个失去双腿的年轻人,他用自己的意志力,克服了生活的重重困难。他的故事,让我明白了责任的意义。他不是在逃避生活的责任,而是在用自己的方式,勇敢地承担着生活的重担。他的责任,让他成为了生活的强者。
I still remember that young man who lost his legs, he used his willpower to overcome the many difficulties of life. His story made me understand the meaning of responsibility. He is not avoiding the responsibility of life, but bravely shouldering the burden of life in his own way. His responsibility made him a strong person in life.
在这个世界上,每个人都有自己的责任。我们的责任,可能不是改变整个世界,但至少可以改变自己的生活。就像那位小村庄的村民,他们的责任是守护自己的家园;就像那位失去双腿的年轻人,他的责任是让自己的人生更加精彩。
In this world, everyone has their own responsibility. Our responsibility may not be to change the whole world, but at least we can change our own lives. Just like the villagers of that small village, their responsibility is to protect their homeland; Just like the young man who lost his legs, his responsibility is to make his life more exciting.
责任,是一种力量,也是一种信念。它让我们在生活的逆境中,依然保持希望,依然相信未来。它让我们在艰难的时刻,依然坚韧不拔,依然勇往直前。
Responsibility is a force and a belief. It allows us to maintain hope and believe in the future even in the adversity of life. It allows us to persevere and move forward bravely in difficult times.
我曾经看过一部关于贫困地区的纪录片,那些孩子们,他们的家庭贫困,他们的生活艰苦,但他们依然努力学习,渴望通过知识改变命运。他们的故事,让我感动,也让我深思。他们的责任,是对自己未来的承诺,是对生活的渴望。
I once watched a documentary about impoverished areas, where children from poor families lived in hardship, but they still worked hard to learn and longed to change their destiny through knowledge. Their stories moved me and made me ponder deeply. Their responsibility is a commitment to their future and a longing for life.
在这个世界上,贫困是不可避免的。但贫困并不是生活的终点,它只是生活的一个阶段。我们的责任,不是去抱怨生活的贫困,而是去努力改变自己的命运。我们的责任,是让自己在这个世界上,无论生活如何艰难,都能找到属于自己的光芒。
Poverty is inevitable in this world. But poverty is not the end of life, it is just a stage of life. Our responsibility is not to complain about poverty in life, but to strive to change our own destiny. Our responsibility is to find our own light in this world, no matter how difficult life may be.
我站在校园的小径上,看着那些忙碌的同学们,心中充满了感慨。他们的责任,是对自己的学业负责,是对自己的未来负责。他们的努力,是为了让自己的人生更加精彩。
I stood on the campus path, watching those busy classmates, and my heart was filled with emotion. Their responsibility is to be responsible for their own studies and their future. Their efforts are to make their lives more exciting.
在这个充满挑战的世界里,让我们都成为那些有责任的人。让我们用自己的努力,去书写属于自己的诗篇。在这个诗篇中,责任是那最坚实的底色,是我们走向幸福的旋律。让我们在生活的舞台上,用责任的力量,奏响属于自己的乐章。
In this challenging world, let us all become responsible individuals. Let us use our own efforts to write our own poems. In this poem, responsibility is the most solid foundation and the melody that leads us towards happiness. Let us play our own music on the stage of life with the power of responsibility.
【佳作赏析】:责任,如风中的芦苇,随风而动
Responsibility, like reeds in the wind, moves with the wind
在这个纷繁复杂的世界里,关于贫困的讨论从未停止。有人说:“当今社会,贫困的最大责任在于自己。”这句话,如同一阵风,吹拂过我的心灵,让我对贫困有了更深的思考。
In this complex world, discussions about poverty have never stopped. Someone once said, "In today's society, the greatest responsibility for poverty lies with oneself." This sentence, like a gust of wind, blew through my soul and made me think more deeply about poverty.
我想起那个在街头卖艺的老人,他身怀绝技,却因贫困而生活在社会的边缘。他的眼神中充满了渴望,却又掩藏着无奈。我曾问他:“为什么不去做一份稳定的工作,至少能保证基本的生活?”他沉默了许久,然后缓缓地说:“生活不易,每个人有自己的难处。”那一刻,我明白了,贫困并非完全是个人选择的结果。
I think of the old man who was performing on the street, possessing unique skills but living on the edge of society due to poverty. His eyes were filled with longing, but also concealed helplessness. I once asked him, "Why not do a stable job that can at least guarantee a basic livelihood?" He remained silent for a long time, then slowly said, "Life is not easy, everyone has their own difficulties." At that moment, I understood that poverty is not entirely the result of personal choices.
贫困,如同一个无形的网,将人们困在其中。它不仅仅是一个经济问题,更是一个社会问题。在这个时代,我们不能忽视这样一个事实:贫困的根源是多方面的,既有个人因素,也有社会因素。
Poverty, like an invisible web, traps people within it. It is not just an economic issue, but also a social issue. In this era, we cannot ignore the fact that the root causes of poverty are multifaceted, including both personal and social factors.
我曾读过一位名叫杰克·伦敦的作家,他的作品《马丁·伊登》讲述了一个关于梦想与现实的故事。马丁·伊登,一个有才华的年轻人,他渴望成功,却始终无法摆脱贫困的阴影。他的故事让我感慨万分,它告诉我,即使是有梦想的人,也可能在贫困面前感到无力和迷茫。
I once read a writer named Jack London whose work "Martin Eden" tells a story about dreams and reality. Martin Eden, a talented young man who yearned for success but could never escape the shadow of poverty. His story left me deeply moved, telling me that even those with dreams can feel powerless and lost in the face of poverty.
然而,我们不能因此就认为贫困完全是个人的责任。事实上,社会环境、教育机会、政策导向等,都在很大程度上影响着一个人的命运。如果我们把贫困的责任完全归咎于个人,那么我们就会忽视那些真正需要帮助的人。
However, we cannot assume that poverty is solely the responsibility of individuals. In fact, social environment, educational opportunities, policy orientation, and other factors all have a significant impact on a person's destiny. If we solely blame individuals for poverty, we will overlook those who truly need help.
我想起那个在山区义务教学的老师,他放弃了大城市优厚的待遇,选择回到家乡,为孩子们传授知识。他的付出,让许多山里的孩子看到了希望,摆脱了贫困。他的故事告诉我,个人的努力虽然重要,但社会的关爱和帮助同样不可或缺。
I think of the teacher who taught voluntarily in the mountainous area. He gave up the generous treatment in big cities and chose to return to his hometown to impart knowledge to the children. His efforts have brought hope to many children in the mountains and lifted them out of poverty. His story tells me that while personal effort is important, social care and assistance are equally indispensable.
在这个时代,我们需要重新审视贫困问题。我们不能简单地归咎于个人,也不能忽视社会的作用。我们需要建立一个更加公平、正义的社会,让每个人都有机会改变自己的命运。
In this era, we need to re-examine the issue of poverty. We cannot simply blame individuals, nor can we ignore the role of society. We need to establish a more fair and just society where everyone has the opportunity to change their destiny.
贫困,如同一片沙漠,让人望而生畏。然而,正是在这片沙漠中,我们才能看到生命的顽强与坚韧。那些在贫困中挣扎的人们,他们用坚定的信念和不懈的努力,诠释着生命的意义。
Poverty, like a desert, is daunting. However, it is in this desert that we can see the tenacity and resilience of life. Those who struggle in poverty interpret the meaning of life with firm beliefs and unremitting efforts.
让我们记住那些在贫困中奋斗的人们,他们如同风中的芦苇,随风而动,却始终不放弃希望。他们的故事,让我们明白,贫困不是生活的终点,而是通向成功的起点。
Let us remember those who struggle in poverty, they are like reeds in the wind, moving with the wind but never giving up hope. Their stories make us understand that poverty is not the end of life, but the starting point towards success.
在这个充满挑战与机遇的时代,让我们携手共进,为那些还在贫困中挣扎的人们带去希望与温暖。让我们用爱心和行动,编织一张温暖的社会网络,让每个人都能够在这个世界上找到属于自己的位置。
In this era full of challenges and opportunities, let us work together to bring hope and warmth to those who are still struggling in poverty. Let us weave a warm social network with love and action, so that everyone can find their own place in this world.
责任,如风中的芦苇,随风而动。让我们在关注个人努力的同时,也不要忘记社会的责任。只有这样,我们才能真正战胜贫困,让每一个人都能在这个世界上绽放光彩。
Responsibility, like reeds in the wind, moves with the wind. Let us not forget our social responsibility while focusing on individual efforts. Only in this way can we truly overcome poverty and enable everyone to shine in this world.